demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity, recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violations of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct, identify conduct that conforms to the Code and Standards and conduct that violates the Code and Standards
Summary:
Standard I: Professionalism, particularly Standard I(A) Knowledge of the Law, emphasizes the obligation of CFA Institute members and candidates to understand and comply with applicable laws, rules, and regulations, including those of the CFA Institute. In cases of conflicting laws, the stricter law must be followed. The guidance provided outlines the relationship between the Code and Standards and applicable law, the responsibilities in cases of violations by others, and considerations for investment products and applicable laws.
Key Concepts:
Compliance with Laws and Regulations
Members and candidates must comply with all applicable laws and regulations in the jurisdictions where they operate. This includes understanding and adhering to stricter laws when conflicts arise between different jurisdictions or between local laws and the CFA Institute's standards.
Dissociation from Violations
If members or candidates become aware of unethical or illegal activities, they must dissociate from those activities. This may involve reporting the issue internally, refusing to participate, or even resigning if necessary to avoid complicity.
Investment Products and Applicable Laws
When dealing with investment products, members and candidates must be aware of the laws and regulations applicable to both the origin and distribution of these products. This ensures compliance and protects the reputation of the firm and the individual.
Global Application of the Code and Standards
Members and candidates working across different jurisdictions must adhere to the stricter of the local laws or the CFA Institute's Code and Standards, ensuring the highest standard of professionalism and ethical conduct.
Standard I(A): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
describe the recommended procedures for Standard I(A)
Summary:
Standard I(A) outlines recommended procedures for members and candidates to ensure compliance with applicable laws, rules, and regulations. It emphasizes the importance of staying informed, reviewing procedures, maintaining current files, understanding distribution area laws, seeking legal counsel when necessary, dissociating from violations, and encouraging firms to adopt comprehensive compliance procedures.
Key Concepts:
Staying Informed
Members and candidates should establish or encourage their employers to establish procedures to keep employees informed about changes in laws, rules, regulations, and case law. This can be achieved through memorandums from the compliance department or legal counsel, and participation in continuing education programs.
Reviewing Procedures
It is recommended that members and candidates review or encourage their employers to review the firm's compliance procedures regularly. This ensures that the procedures are up-to-date with current laws and provide clear guidance on permissible conduct.
Maintaining Current Files
Members and candidates should maintain or encourage their employers to maintain accessible reference copies of applicable statutes, rules, regulations, and important cases to ensure compliance and readiness for reference when needed.
Understanding Distribution Area Laws
Members and candidates should make reasonable efforts to understand the laws applicable in the countries and regions where their investment products are developed and distributed.
Seeking Legal Counsel
When unsure about the appropriate actions to take, members and candidates are advised to seek guidance from compliance personnel or legal counsel, especially if potential violations are observed.
Dissociation from Violations
In cases where there is a violation of the Code and Standards, members and candidates should document the violation, urge cessation, and may need to dissociate from the activity, potentially by resigning.
Encouraging Firms to Adopt Compliance Procedures
Members and candidates should encourage their firms to develop or adopt a code of ethics, provide information on applicable laws, and establish procedures for reporting violations to support the principles of Standard I(A).
Standard I(A): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
This LOS focuses on demonstrating the application of the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct in various professional scenarios that test integrity. It includes examples where individuals must decide how to act ethically in complex situations involving potential legal or ethical violations.
Key Concepts:
Notification of Known Violations
Individuals are encouraged to report any known violations to appropriate authorities or supervisors within their firms, even if legal counsel suggests that involvement may be difficult to prove.
Dissociating from a Violation
If an individual discovers unethical practices within their firm and these are not addressed after reporting, the individual should dissociate from the activity, which may include severing connections with the project or seeking employment elsewhere.
Following the Highest Requirements
Professionals must adhere to the most stringent ethical and legal standards available, whether those are set by local laws, the host country's laws, or the CFA Institute's standards, especially in cases where local regulations may be less rigorous.
Laws and Regulations Based on Religious Tenets
Professionals must be aware of and respect cultural and religious laws when managing funds or advising clients from different cultural or religious backgrounds.
Reporting Potential Unethical Actions
Employees should follow established procedures within their firms for reporting unethical behavior, which may include discussions with supervisors or compliance departments.
Failure to Maintain Knowledge of the Law
Professionals must keep themselves updated with all relevant laws and regulations, including those governing new technologies and platforms they use to communicate with clients.
Standard I(B) Independence and Objectivity
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
Standard I(B) Independence and Objectivity emphasizes the need for CFA Institute members and candidates to maintain independence and objectivity in their professional activities. It outlines the potential conflicts of interest that may arise from various relationships and scenarios, such as buy-side and sell-side analysts, investment banking, issuer-paid research, and corporate influences. The standard advises on practices to mitigate these conflicts, ensuring that members' and candidates' decisions and recommendations are not compromised.
Key Concepts:
Gifts and Entertainment
Members and candidates must not accept gifts, benefits, or compensation that could be expected to compromise their objectivity and independence. Modest gifts and entertainment are permissible, but care must be taken to avoid any appearance of bias.
Issuer-Paid Research
Analysts must conduct issuer-paid research with independence and disclose any potential conflicts of interest, including the nature of their compensation. The research must be based on thorough, unbiased analysis and clearly differentiate between facts and opinions.
Investment Banking Relationships
Sell-side firms may pressure analysts to produce favorable research for investment banking clients. Best practices include maintaining strict firewalls between research and investment banking divisions to prevent conflicts of interest.
Performance Measurement and Attribution
Performance analysts must maintain objectivity when evaluating investment managers' adherence to their mandates and must resist any internal or external pressures to alter performance results.
Travel Funding
Accepting travel funding from companies can compromise independence. Members and candidates should use commercial transportation at their own or their firm's expense to avoid conflicts of interest.
Standard I(B): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
Describe the recommended procedures for adhering to Standard I(B).
Summary:
Standard I(B) of the CFA Institute's ethical guidelines focuses on maintaining independence and objectivity in professional conduct. It outlines specific recommended procedures that members and candidates should follow to avoid conflicts of interest and ensure the integrity of their opinions and research. These procedures include establishing policies for unbiased research reports, creating restricted lists for controversial companies, restricting special cost arrangements, limiting gifts, restricting investments, reviewing procedures, maintaining independence in research, and appointing an oversight officer.
Key Concepts:
Protecting the integrity of opinions
Members and candidates should ensure that research reports reflect unbiased opinions and that compensation systems do not compromise the independence of analysts.
Creating a restricted list
Firms should create a restricted list for companies about which they cannot disseminate adverse opinions, limiting dissemination to only factual information.
Restricting special cost arrangements
Members should pay for their own travel and accommodations when visiting issuer's headquarters and avoid accepting reimbursements for such expenses from corporate issuers.
Limiting gifts
Members must limit the acceptance of gifts to token items and ensure that business-related entertainment does not serve to influence or reward them.
Restricting investments
Investment firms should develop formal policies regarding employee participation in IPOs and private placements, requiring prior approval and prompt disclosure of investment actions.
Reviewing procedures
Firms should implement supervisory and review procedures to ensure compliance with personal investment activity policies.
Maintaining independence in research
A formal written policy should be established to maintain the independence and objectivity of research, with appropriate reporting structures and review procedures.
Appointing an oversight officer
A senior officer should be appointed to oversee compliance with the firm's ethical code and regulations, and procedures should be in place for reporting unethical behavior or regulatory violations.
Standard I(B): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Standard I(B) in various scenarios
Summary:
Standard I(B) focuses on maintaining independence and objectivity in professional activities. The examples provided illustrate various scenarios where financial analysts and investment professionals must navigate potential conflicts of interest, pressures from within their firms, and external influences to uphold the integrity of their analyses and recommendations.
Key Concepts:
Independence and Objectivity
Professionals must ensure that their judgments and recommendations are not influenced by potential conflicts of interest, whether from internal pressures, external relationships, or personal gain.
Disclosure of Conflicts
When potential conflicts of interest arise, it is crucial for professionals to disclose these conflicts to their supervisors or relevant parties to maintain transparency and trust.
Handling Pressure
Professionals must resist pressures from within their organization or from external entities that might compromise their objectivity or push them towards unethical practices.
Gifts and Entertainment
Accepting gifts or entertainment can be permissible under certain conditions, but must always be disclosed and should not influence business decisions or actions.
Compensation Arrangements
Compensation structures should not create incentives that might lead professionals to act against the interests of their clients or compromise their objectivity.
Standard I(C) Misrepresentation
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
Standard I(C) Misrepresentation focuses on the ethical responsibilities of members and candidates in the investment profession to avoid misrepresentations in all forms of communication and activities. This includes ensuring accuracy in investment practice, performance reporting, use of social media, handling omissions, avoiding plagiarism, and maintaining integrity in work completed for employers. The standard emphasizes the importance of trust and integrity in maintaining investor confidence and the proper functioning of capital markets.
Key Concepts:
Impact on Investment Practice
Members and candidates must accurately represent all aspects of their practice including qualifications, services, performance records, and investment characteristics to maintain trust and integrity in the investment profession.
Performance Reporting
Misrepresentations in performance reporting can occur through inappropriate benchmark selection or inconsistent reporting standards. Best practices involve transparent and appropriate benchmark presentation to aid clients in making informed investment decisions.
Social Media
The use of social media by members and candidates must adhere to the same standards of honesty and integrity as traditional forms of communication. Misrepresentations through these platforms are considered violations of Standard I(C).
Omissions
Omitting crucial information, especially in the use of models and technical analysis, can mislead investors. Members and candidates must ensure all relevant information is included to provide a true and fair view of the investment opportunities.
Plagiarism
Copying or using materials prepared by others without proper acknowledgment is prohibited. Members and candidates must credit original sources to avoid misrepresentation and maintain professional integrity.
Work Completed for Employer
Research and models developed within a firm are the property of the firm. Members and candidates must respect these rights and avoid misrepresentations when using or sharing such work.
Standard I(C): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
Standard I(C): Recommended Procedures
Summary:
Standard I(C) outlines the recommended procedures to ensure factual presentations, proper qualification summaries, and verification of outside information to prevent misrepresentation and maintain integrity in client communications and reports. It emphasizes the importance of accurate and complete presentations, preparation of qualification summaries by members, and verification of third-party information to uphold the reputation and trust in financial services.
Key Concepts:
Factual Presentations
Members and candidates should ensure that all presentations and communications with clients or potential clients are accurate and complete. Firms should guide employees on how to describe services and qualifications accurately without misrepresentation.
Qualification Summary
Members and candidates should prepare a summary of their qualifications and capabilities to ensure accurate presentations to clients. Firms should assist by periodically reviewing representations of qualifications in communications.
Verify Outside Information
When using third-party information in client communications, members and candidates must verify the accuracy of this information to prevent misrepresentation and maintain integrity.
Maintain Webpages
Members and candidates should regularly monitor their webpages to ensure the information is current, accurate, and does not misrepresent any facts. This includes maintaining the security and confidentiality of the webpage.
Plagiarism Policy
To avoid plagiarism, members and candidates should maintain records of all research materials and sources used in preparing reports, attribute direct quotations and summaries to their sources, and ensure all paraphrased material is properly attributed.
Standard I(C): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
Demonstrate the application of Standard I(C) in various scenarios.
Summary:
Standard I(C) of the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct focuses on the avoidance of misrepresentation and plagiarism. This LOS explores various examples where the standard is applied, illustrating both compliance and violations through scenarios involving disclosure, error correction, plagiarism, and misrepresentation of information.
Key Concepts:
Disclosure of Issuer-Paid Research
Analysts must disclose any contractual relationships with companies they cover to avoid misleading potential investors, even if their research is valid and thorough.
Correction of Unintentional Errors
When errors in published information are discovered, they must be corrected promptly to prevent the spread of misinformation, even if the errors were unintentional.
Noncorrection of Known Errors
Failing to correct known errors, especially when they involve misrepresentation of qualifications or other critical information, constitutes a violation of Standard I(C).
Plagiarism
Using others' work without proper attribution, whether it's data, text, or ideas, is a violation of Standard I(C). Proper credit must be given to the original sources.
Misrepresentation of Information
Providing false or misleading information about investment products, such as guarantees or risk levels, violates Standard I(C). Accurate and truthful representation is crucial.
Potential Information Misrepresentation
Advisors must clarify the terms under which certain financial products are 'guaranteed' and ensure clients understand the conditions and limitations of such guarantees.
Avoiding a Misrepresentation
Choosing not to invest in securities that the team cannot fully understand or explain to clients helps in complying with Standard I(C) by avoiding potential misrepresentations.
Misrepresenting Composite Construction
"Cherry picking" accounts to manipulate performance data in reports is a misrepresentation and violates Standard I(C). Transparency in composite construction is required.
Presenting Out-of-Date Information
Distributing outdated information that does not reflect current conditions or changes in investment products misleads clients and violates Standard I(C).
Overemphasis of Firm Results
Highlighting only the positive outcomes from a subset of funds while ignoring broader performance can mislead potential clients about the overall success of the firm.
Standard I(D) Misconduct
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity, recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violations of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct, identify conduct that conforms to the Code and Standards and conduct that violates the Code and Standards
Summary:
Standard I(D) Misconduct addresses the professional integrity, reputation, or competence of members and candidates in the finance industry. It emphasizes the importance of honesty and ethical behavior in professional conduct and outlines the consequences of misconduct, which includes any dishonest or deceitful behavior that adversely affects a member's professional activities. The standard also provides guidance on recommended procedures and practices to prevent misconduct and ensure compliance with ethical standards.
Key Concepts:
Misconduct Definition
Misconduct under Standard I(D) includes any professional conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or any act that reflects adversely on a member's professional reputation, integrity, or competence.
Impact of Personal Behavior
Personal behavior that negatively impacts trustworthiness or competence, even if not illegal, can constitute a violation of Standard I(D). Examples include substance abuse during business hours or fraudulent activities leading to personal bankruptcy.
Recommended Procedures
To prevent misconduct, members and candidates should encourage their firms to adopt ethical codes, disseminate lists of potential violations with disciplinary actions, and verify the character and eligibility of potential employees.
Application of Standard I(D)
Real-world examples, such as a trust investment officer exhibiting poor judgment due to intoxication, illustrate the application of Standard I(D) and the importance of maintaining professionalism and competence in all professional activities.
Standard I(D): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
Describe Standard I(D): Recommended Procedures
Summary:
Standard I(D) emphasizes the importance of maintaining integrity and trust in the investment profession. It outlines the expected conduct of members and candidates in ensuring due diligence in their professional activities to uphold the trust placed in them by clients. The standard also addresses the misuse of the CFA Institute Professional Conduct Program for personal or unrelated disputes and recommends procedures for firms to support the principles of Standard I(D).
Key Concepts:
Impact of Personal Bankruptcy
Personal bankruptcy does not necessarily impact a person's integrity unless it involves fraudulent or deceitful business conduct, which would then be a violation of Standard I(D).
Due Diligence and Trust
Members and candidates are expected to conduct necessary due diligence before making investment recommendations. Failure to do so can breach client trust and damage the reputation of the financial market.
Misuse of Professional Conduct Program
There are instances where individuals may misuse the CFA Institute Professional Conduct Program to settle personal or political disputes. The CFA Institute has policies to handle such misuse.
Recommended Procedures for Firms
Firms are encouraged to adopt specific policies such as a code of ethics, a list of violations with disciplinary actions, and thorough checks on potential employees' references to support Standard I(D).
Application Example: Professionalism and Competence
An example provided involves a trust investment officer who makes professional decisions while intoxicated, demonstrating a lack of professionalism and competence, potentially violating Standard I(D).
Standard I(D): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
Standard I(D) of the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct focuses on maintaining professional integrity by avoiding misconduct such as fraud, deceit, and professional incompetence. The standard emphasizes the importance of personal behavior that upholds the trust and reputation of the investment profession. Examples provided illustrate various scenarios where Standard I(D) is applied, highlighting the consequences of actions that compromise professional integrity.
Key Concepts:
Professionalism and Competence
Professionalism and competence are crucial in maintaining the integrity of the investment profession. Actions that compromise these, such as intoxication during work hours, reflect poorly on the individual and the profession, violating Standard I(D).
Fraud and Deceit
Engaging in fraudulent or deceitful activities, such as altering reimbursement forms or manipulating purchasing agreements for personal gain, directly violates Standard I(D) as these actions compromise the integrity and trust placed in professionals.
Personal Actions and Integrity
Personal actions, even if legal or part of civil disobedience, do not necessarily violate Standard I(D) if they do not reflect poorly on professional integrity or competence. For example, nonviolent protests for personal beliefs are generally not covered under this standard.
Professional Misconduct
Encountering and not reporting unethical activities within a firm, especially when they affect financial reporting or performance, can be seen as professional misconduct under Standard I(D). Professionals are encouraged to report such activities to maintain integrity.
Standard I(E) Competence
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity, recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violations of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct, identify conduct that conforms to the Code and Standards and conduct that violates the Code and Standards
Summary:
Standard I(E) Competence under the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct requires members and candidates to maintain the necessary knowledge, skills, and diligence to fulfill their professional responsibilities effectively. This standard emphasizes the importance of integrity, competence, and continuous improvement in professional competence. It also outlines recommended procedures for achieving and maintaining competence, such as engaging in professional development and continuing education.
Key Concepts:
Competence
Competence refers to having the appropriate knowledge, skills, and abilities required to perform professional duties effectively. It involves applying information directly to the performance of functions, the capability to perform specific tasks, and the attitudes that support successful outcomes.
Continuous Improvement
Members and candidates are encouraged to continuously maintain or improve their professional competence. This involves regular participation in professional development activities, earning certifications, and engaging in self-study to stay updated with relevant knowledge and skills.
Professional Development Activities
To maintain competence, members and candidates should engage in activities such as attending conferences, seminars, webinars, participating in training offered by employers, and joining expert groups or organizations. These activities help professionals stay competent in their roles and adapt to new or expanded responsibilities.
Standard I(E): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
Describe Standard I(E): Recommended Procedures
Summary:
Standard I(E) of the CFA Institute's ethical guidelines focuses on the importance of maintaining and enhancing professional competence. It outlines recommended procedures for achieving and maintaining competence, which include engaging in continuous professional development and education, earning relevant certifications, and adapting to new responsibilities. The standard emphasizes that competence is not solely based on educational level but also on the application of knowledge, skills, and abilities in a professional setting.
Key Concepts:
Competence
Competence refers to having the necessary knowledge, skills, and abilities to perform a professional role successfully. It is not solely determined by educational achievements but also by the effective application and continuous development of these attributes.
Continuous Professional Development
Continuous professional development involves regularly engaging in activities that enhance one's professional abilities and knowledge. This can include formal education programs, self-study, attending seminars, and participating in relevant training and conferences.
Adaptation to Role Changes
Professionals are required to adapt and update their competence when their job roles change or expand. This may involve acquiring new skills or knowledge to meet the demands of the new responsibilities effectively.
Standard I(E): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
Demonstrate the application of Standard I(E) in various professional scenarios.
Summary:
Standard I(E) focuses on maintaining and improving competence in professional roles. It emphasizes the importance of staying updated with relevant knowledge and skills, especially when professional responsibilities change or new roles are assumed. The examples provided illustrate different scenarios where professionals either meet or fail to meet the standard by either enhancing their competence or neglecting necessary learning and adaptation.
Key Concepts:
Maintaining Competence
Professionals must continuously update their knowledge and skills relevant to their job functions. This involves staying informed about significant developments in their field and consulting with experts to ensure accurate understanding.
Improving Competence
When new elements such as ESG considerations become relevant to a professional's role, it is crucial to acquire the necessary knowledge and skills, either through hiring experts, training, or certification.
Change in Role
Transitioning to a new role requires understanding and mastering the specific knowledge and skills pertinent to that role. Merely relying on past experience or unrelated knowledge does not suffice.
Supervisory Responsibility
Upon assuming a supervisory role, a professional must acquire management and compliance skills in addition to maintaining their existing expertise to effectively oversee their team.
Choosing Investments
Financial planners must conduct thorough and appropriate research before recommending investments. However, unforeseen events like fraud that were not detectable through reasonable investigation do not necessarily reflect incompetence.
Understanding New Investment Products
Professionals should not engage in or recommend new investment products without a thorough understanding of their nature and suitability for clients, regardless of market trends or client pressure.
Standard II: Integrity of Capital Markets
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity, recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violations of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct, identify conduct that conforms to the Code and Standards and conduct that violates the Code and Standards
Summary:
Standard II: Integrity of Capital Markets focuses on maintaining the integrity of capital markets by prohibiting the use of material nonpublic information for trading or influencing trading decisions. It emphasizes the importance of public confidence in the fairness and efficiency of the markets, which is crucial for the functioning of vibrant economies. The standard covers various aspects including what constitutes material and nonpublic information, the mosaic theory, the use of social media, engaging industry experts, and the dissemination of investment research reports.
Key Concepts:
Material Information
Information is considered 'material' if its disclosure would likely impact the price of a security or if reasonable investors would want to know the information before making an investment decision. Factors such as the specificity, difference from public information, nature, and reliability of the information help determine its materiality.
Nonpublic Information
Information is 'nonpublic' until it has been disseminated to the marketplace in general. This includes ensuring the information is available beyond a select group of investors and is widely accessible through common channels like press releases or internet postings.
Mosaic Theory
Under the mosaic theory, analysts can use a combination of public and nonmaterial nonpublic information to form investment recommendations. This theory supports the idea that analysts can derive conclusions from a broad array of data without violating the standard concerning material nonpublic information.
Social Media
The use of social media in disseminating or gathering information must be handled carefully to ensure that any material information shared is already public or becomes public through proper channels to avoid selective disclosure.
Using Industry Experts
While engaging with industry experts can provide valuable insights, members and candidates must ensure that they do not receive or act upon confidential or protected information that could be considered material nonpublic.
Investment Research Reports
Analysts' reports based on public information and nonmaterial nonpublic information (mosaic theory) do not necessarily have to be made public if they are the result of the analyst's own research and analysis.
Standard II(A): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
describe Standard II(A): Recommended Procedures
Summary:
Standard II(A) outlines recommended procedures for achieving public dissemination of material information, adopting compliance and disclosure procedures, issuing press releases, establishing firewalls, managing interdepartmental communications, limiting personal trading, maintaining records, managing proprietary trading, and communicating policies to all employees. These procedures aim to prevent the misuse of material nonpublic information and ensure equitable information dissemination in the marketplace.
Key Concepts:
Achieve Public Dissemination
Members should make reasonable efforts to publicly disseminate material information, primarily by encouraging the issuing company to make the information public. If not possible, the information should be restricted to supervisory and compliance personnel without taking investment action based on it.
Adopt Compliance Procedures
Firms are encouraged to adopt compliance procedures that prevent the misuse of material nonpublic information, including reviewing trading activities, documenting procedures, and supervising interdepartmental communications.
Adopt Disclosure Procedures
Firms should develop and follow disclosure policies to ensure equitable dissemination of information to the marketplace, avoiding discrimination among analysts or providing selective information.
Issue Press Releases
Companies should issue press releases prior to analyst meetings and script such meetings to prevent the disclosure of additional material nonpublic information.
Firewall Elements
Firewalls prevent the communication of material nonpublic information within firms. Elements include controlling interdepartmental communications, reviewing employee trading, documenting procedures, and restricting proprietary trading when possessing sensitive information.
Appropriate Interdepartmental Communications
Firms should document and formalize procedures concerning interdepartmental communication to prevent the leakage of sensitive information.
Personal Trading Limitations
Firms should impose restrictions on personal trading by employees, monitor trading activities, and require periodic reporting of transactions.
Record Maintenance
Firms should maintain written records of communications between departments and prioritize training to handle sensitive information appropriately.
Proprietary Trading Procedures
Firms should have procedures to manage proprietary trading when in possession of material nonpublic information, adjusting activities based on the type of trading involved.
Communication to All Employees
Firms should circulate written compliance policies to all employees and provide training to recognize and handle material nonpublic information correctly.
Standard II(A): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
Demonstrate the application of Standard II(A) in various scenarios involving nonpublic information.
Summary:
Standard II(A) of the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct focuses on the prohibition of using material nonpublic information in trading and investment decisions. The examples provided illustrate various scenarios where individuals either comply with or violate this standard by either using or mishandling nonpublic information.
Key Concepts:
Material Nonpublic Information
Information that could influence the market price of a security and that has not been made available to the public. Using such information for trading purposes is considered unethical and illegal in many jurisdictions.
Mosaic Theory
A legitimate research approach where an analyst pieces together non-material nonpublic information with public information to make investment decisions. This practice is permissible under Standard II(A) as it does not rely solely on material nonpublic information.
Selective Disclosure
Occurs when material information is disclosed to a select group rather than the public, leading to potential unfair advantages. Analysts receiving such information must verify its public availability before acting on it.
Controlling Nonpublic Information
Firms are required to establish barriers and enforce policies to prevent the misuse of nonpublic information, ensuring that it does not inadvertently or deliberately influence unauthorized trading activities.
Expert Networks
Networks used to gain insights from industry experts. While using expert networks is allowed, care must be taken to ensure that no material nonpublic information is exchanged during such consultations.
Standard II(B) Market Manipulation
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity, recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violations of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct, identify conduct that conforms to the Code and Standards and conduct that violates the Code and Standards
Summary:
Standard II(B) Market Manipulation under the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct requires members and candidates to avoid engaging in market manipulation, which includes any practices that distort security prices or trading volumes with the intent to mislead market participants. This standard is crucial for maintaining market integrity and investor confidence by ensuring that financial markets operate smoothly without deceptive practices.
Key Concepts:
Information-Based Manipulation
This type of manipulation involves spreading false or misleading information to influence market prices. Examples include issuing overly optimistic information about a security to inflate its price artificially, then selling it at this inflated price.
Transaction-Based Manipulation
This manipulation occurs through trading actions that misleadingly affect market prices or volumes, such as conducting trades that give a false impression of market activity or controlling a significant portion of a security to manipulate its price or the price of related derivatives.
Legitimate Trading vs. Manipulation
Standard II(B) does not prevent transactions based on legitimate trading strategies that aim to capitalize on market inefficiencies. The critical factor in determining a violation is the intent behind the transactions, whether they aim to deceive or manipulate market participants.
Standard II(B): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
Demonstrate the application of Standard II(B) through various examples.
Summary:
Standard II(B) focuses on ensuring that financial professionals do not engage in practices that manipulate market prices or trading volumes. The examples provided illustrate various scenarios where individuals or entities could potentially violate this standard by engaging in activities such as spreading false information, manipulating trading volumes, or using misleading model inputs to influence market prices or perceptions.
Key Concepts:
Independent Analysis and Company Promotion
Using misleading information or inaccurate reporting under the guise of independent analysis to artificially inflate stock prices violates Standard II(B).
Personal Trading Practices and Price
Creating false market perceptions through rumor campaigns and strategic trading to maintain or increase stock prices constitutes a violation.
Creating Artificial Price Volatility
Timing the release of speculative or inaccurate research reports to affect stock prices, especially to benefit certain clients, is a breach of Standard II(B).
Personal Trading and Volume
Manipulating trading volumes between funds to influence stock prices, even if intended to benefit fund participants, is prohibited.
"Pump-Priming" Strategy
Misleading market participants about the liquidity of a financial instrument, even if the intent is to improve service, requires full disclosure to avoid violation.
Pump and Dump Strategy
Spreading false information to inflate stock prices before selling the inflated stocks ('pump and dump') is a clear violation of Standard II(B).
Manipulating Model Inputs
Using overly positive scenarios in financial models to obtain favorable ratings or prices, without considering realistic risks, manipulates market perceptions and violates the standard.
Information Manipulation
Using false identities to spread rumors affecting stock prices, regardless of personal profit, misleads investors and violates Standard II(B).
Standard III: Duties to Clients
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
Standard III: Duties to Clients emphasizes the importance of loyalty, prudence, and care in managing client relationships and investments. It outlines the responsibilities of members and candidates to act in the best interest of their clients, prioritizing client interests over their own or their employer’s. The standard also addresses the complexities of identifying the actual client, managing potential conflicts of interest, and ensuring that investment decisions align with the client’s objectives and risk tolerance.
Key Concepts:
Loyalty, Prudence, and Care
Members and candidates must prioritize client interests, act with care, and exercise prudent judgment in all investment decisions, ensuring actions are taken with the client’s best interests in mind.
Identifying the Actual Investment Client
It is crucial to accurately identify the client to whom loyalty is owed, which may not always be the entity hiring the investment manager but could be the beneficiaries of a trust or pension plan.
Developing the Client’s Portfolio
Investment strategies should be aligned with the client’s long-term objectives and risk tolerance, and potential conflicts of interest should be managed transparently.
Soft Commission Policies
Members and candidates must ensure that any brokerage commissions paid from client accounts for research services provide corresponding benefits to the client.
Proxy Voting Policies
The duty of loyalty extends to voting proxies in an informed manner that maximizes value for the client, considering the economic impact of proxy votes.
Standard III(A): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
Describe Standard III(A): Recommended Procedures
Summary:
Standard III(A) outlines the recommended procedures for members and candidates who have control over client assets. It emphasizes the importance of regular account information, client approval for questionable matters, and adherence to firm policies that prioritize client interests and compliance with legal and ethical standards.
Key Concepts:
Regular Account Information
Members and candidates should provide quarterly itemized statements to clients showing all account transactions and asset details, disclose asset maintenance locations, and keep client assets separate from others.
Client Approval
In cases of uncertainty regarding the appropriate course of action, members and candidates should seek written approval from clients after fully disclosing the matter in question.
Firm Policies
Firms should have clear policies covering legal compliance, client investment objectives, investment suitability, diversification, regular reviews, fair treatment of clients, conflict of interest disclosures, compensation disclosures, proxy voting, client confidentiality, and seeking best execution.
Standard III(A): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
Demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity.
Summary:
Standard III(A) of the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct focuses on the duty of loyalty, prudence, and care that members and candidates must uphold. This standard requires that investment professionals act in the best interests of their clients, maintain confidentiality, disclose conflicts of interest, and seek best execution of trades. The examples provided illustrate various scenarios where these principles are either upheld or violated, emphasizing the importance of ethical decision-making in the finance industry.
Key Concepts:
Duty of Loyalty
Members and candidates must act for the benefit of their clients and place their clients' interests before their own or their employer's interests.
Prudence and Care
Investment actions must be made with competence and diligence, ensuring that decisions are based on thorough analysis and reflect the client's objectives.
Fair Dealing
All clients should be treated fairly. This includes providing equal access to investment opportunities and avoiding actions that advantage one client over another without just cause.
Confidentiality
Client information must be kept confidential unless the client permits disclosure or it is required by law.
Disclosure of Conflicts
All actual and potential conflicts of interest must be disclosed to clients to allow them to make informed decisions about the services provided.
Best Execution
Members and candidates must seek the best execution of trades for their clients, considering the terms and conditions of the trade and the capabilities of the execution venue.
Standard III(B) Fair Dealing
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
Standard III(B) Fair Dealing requires members and candidates to treat all clients fairly when disseminating investment recommendations or taking investment actions. This standard ensures that all clients have a fair opportunity to act on recommendations and that investment actions are taken considering the clients' objectives and circumstances. The guidance emphasizes the importance of equitable treatment in the dissemination of recommendations and the allocation of investment opportunities, ensuring no client is unfairly disadvantaged.
Key Concepts:
Fair Treatment in Investment Recommendations
Members and candidates must ensure that investment recommendations are disseminated in a manner that allows all clients a fair opportunity to act on them. This involves managing the timing and method of communication to prevent selective or discriminatory disclosure.
Equitable Allocation in Investment Actions
When taking investment actions, such as managing portfolios or allocating new issues, members and candidates must distribute opportunities fairly among clients. This includes prorating oversubscribed issues and avoiding favoritism, even among family members unless similar management is applied to other clients.
Disclosure and Compliance Procedures
Members and candidates should disclose the allocation procedures to clients and encourage their firms to establish compliance procedures that promote fair dealing. These procedures should be clear, documented, and communicated to all relevant parties.
Standard III(B): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
Describe Standard III(B): Recommended Procedures
Summary:
Standard III(B) emphasizes the importance of fair and objective treatment of clients by members and candidates, recommending the development of firm policies and procedures to ensure compliance. These procedures should include systematic account reviews, fair trade allocation, and clear disclosure of levels of service and trade allocation procedures to clients.
Key Concepts:
Develop Firm Policies
Firms should establish compliance procedures to ensure all employees treat customers and clients fairly when disseminating investment recommendations or taking investment actions. Formal written procedures should be in place, especially for investment advisers, to ensure fair treatment of all clients.
Disclose Trade Allocation Procedures
Members and candidates must disclose how accounts are selected for participation in orders and how securities are allocated among accounts. These procedures must be fair and equitable, and simply disclosing inequitable methods does not absolve the member of the obligation to ensure fairness.
Establish Systematic Account Review
Regular reviews of each account should be conducted to ensure no preferential treatment is given and that investment actions are suitable for each account’s objectives. Investment decisions should be documented, especially when different actions are taken for similar accounts.
Disclose Levels of Service
All clients should be informed about different levels of service that may be offered for the same or different fees. Such offerings should not be selective among clients to ensure fairness and transparency.
Standard III(B): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
Demonstrate the application of Standard III(B) in various scenarios.
Summary:
Standard III(B) of the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct focuses on fair dealing and equitable treatment of all clients. This standard requires that investment professionals must not discriminate among clients and must treat all clients fairly in terms of investment opportunities, information dissemination, and transaction execution. The examples provided illustrate various breaches of this standard, emphasizing the importance of systematic procedures, equal information distribution, and avoidance of conflicts of interest.
Key Concepts:
Selective Disclosure
Selective disclosure refers to sharing potentially market-moving, non-public information with a subset of clients, which is a violation of fair dealing as it gives an unfair advantage to those clients over others.
Fair Dealing between Funds
This concept involves treating all client funds equitably, especially when managing multiple funds with similar objectives. Prioritizing one fund over another, or discretionary over non-discretionary accounts, without a fair system, breaches this standard.
Fair Dealing and IPO Distribution
In the context of initial public offerings (IPOs), fair dealing requires equitable distribution of shares among all eligible clients. Favoring certain clients or personal accounts violates this standard.
Fair Dealing and Transaction Allocation
This involves the equitable allocation of trades among clients. Allocating profitable trades to preferred clients and unprofitable ones to others without a predefined fair system is a violation.
Additional Services for Select Clients
While offering additional services to larger clients isn't a violation per se, it becomes one if basic services or opportunities are withheld from smaller clients or if additional services are not disclosed.
Minimum Lot Allocations
This refers to the allocation of securities in situations where demand exceeds supply. A fair system, such as pro-rata allocation, should be used unless minimum lot sizes dictate otherwise.
Excessive Trading
Engaging in excessive trading to benefit one client at the expense of others, such as to secure research or other services, is unfair and violates this standard.
Limited Social Media Disclosures
Using social media to disclose recommendations to a select group before a general release is considered selective disclosure and is unfair to other clients.
Standard III(C) Suitability
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity, recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violations of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct, identify conduct that conforms to the Code and Standards and conduct that violates the Code and Standards
Summary:
Standard III(C) Suitability emphasizes the importance of suitability in investment advisory relationships, requiring members and candidates to carefully consider the client's needs, circumstances, and objectives when determining the appropriateness of investments. It involves developing and regularly updating an Investment Policy Statement (IPS), understanding and managing the client's risk profile, addressing unsolicited trading requests, and ensuring investments align with the client's overall portfolio and stated objectives.
Key Concepts:
Investment Policy Statement (IPS)
An IPS is a written document that outlines the client's financial circumstances, risk tolerance, return requirements, and investment constraints. It serves as a guideline for making investment decisions and is regularly updated to reflect changes in the client's situation or objectives.
Client's Risk Profile
Understanding the client's risk tolerance is crucial in determining suitable investments. This involves assessing how much risk the client is willing and able to take and considering the potential impact of changing market conditions on the client's investments.
Diversification
Diversification is a risk management strategy that mixes a wide variety of investments within a portfolio. It is considered essential for reducing risk and achieving a more stable return over time.
Unsolicited Trading Requests
Members and candidates may receive trade requests from clients that do not align with the investment policy. It is their responsibility to educate the client on how these requests deviate from the policy and to obtain client acknowledgment of the risks involved before proceeding.
Managing to an Index or Mandate
For members and candidates managing funds to a specific index or mandate, it is crucial to ensure that investments are consistent with the stated objectives of the fund. They are not responsible for assessing the suitability of the fund for individual investors.
Standard III(C): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
Describe Standard III(C): Recommended Procedures
Summary:
Standard III(C) emphasizes the importance of creating and maintaining a tailored investment policy statement (IPS) for each client, regularly updating it to reflect changes in client circumstances or market conditions, and developing firm policies for conducting suitability tests. These procedures ensure that investment recommendations are aligned with the client's objectives, constraints, and risk tolerance.
Key Concepts:
Investment Policy Statement (IPS)
An IPS is a written document that outlines the client's investment objectives and constraints. It includes details such as client identification, investor objectives, investor constraints, and performance measurement benchmarks. This document serves as a guideline for making investment decisions that align with the client's goals and circumstances.
Regular Updates
The IPS should be reviewed and updated regularly to ensure it remains relevant to the client's current financial situation and market conditions. This may involve adjusting the asset allocation based on changes in client circumstances or capital market expectations. Regular reviews, typically annually, are recommended unless specific events warrant more frequent updates.
Suitability Test Policies
With regulatory requirements for suitability tests increasing, firms are encouraged to develop policies and procedures that ensure investments are suitable for clients. These tests should consider factors beyond potential returns, such as the impact on portfolio diversification, alignment with the client's risk tolerance, and the overall investment strategy.
Standard III(C): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
Demonstrate the application of Standard III(C) in various investment scenarios.
Summary:
Standard III(C) focuses on ensuring that investment recommendations and actions are suitable to the client's financial circumstances, investment experience, and objectives. This LOS explores various examples where investment professionals either adhere to or violate this standard by assessing the suitability of investments based on clients' risk profiles, entire portfolio considerations, and investment policy statements (IPS).
Key Concepts:
Investment Suitability—Risk Profile
Investment suitability must be tailored to individual client's risk tolerance and financial circumstances. For example, recommending high-risk investments to a client who seeks stability and has a low risk tolerance is inappropriate and violates Standard III(C).
Investment Suitability—Entire Portfolio
Advisors must consider the impact of new investments on the entire portfolio, ensuring that recommendations align with the overall investment strategy and client's risk profile.
IPS Updating
Changes in a client's financial situation or objectives necessitate updates to the IPS to reflect new circumstances and ensure continued suitability of the investment strategy.
Following an Investment Mandate
Investment actions must adhere to the stated fund mandate or IPS. Deviations from the mandate without proper adjustments or disclosures can lead to violations of Standard III(C).
IPS Requirements and Limitations
Investment decisions should respect the constraints and requirements outlined in the IPS. Engaging in investments that do not meet these criteria, such as illiquid investments when liquidity is a requirement, is a breach of the standard.
Submanager and IPS Reviews
When outsourcing to submanagers, due diligence is required to ensure their strategies align with clients' IPSs. Decisions should not be based solely on cost but should consider suitability and alignment with client needs.
Standard III(D) Performance Presentation
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity, recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violations of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct, identify conduct that conforms to the Code and Standards and conduct that violates the Code and Standards
Summary:
Standard III(D) Performance Presentation mandates that members and candidates provide credible, fair, accurate, and complete performance information to clients and prospective clients. It prohibits misrepresentations of past or expected performance and requires full disclosure of investment performance data. The standard applies to individual accounts, composites, and pooled funds, and emphasizes compliance with GIPS standards or equivalent measures to ensure the integrity of performance presentations.
Key Concepts:
Credible Performance Information
Members and candidates must ensure that the performance information they provide is not only accurate but also credible, avoiding any misrepresentations or misleading data about past or expected performance.
Full Disclosure
This concept involves the complete and thorough disclosure of all relevant performance data to clients and prospective clients, ensuring that all communicated performance information is fair and comprehensive.
GIPS Compliance
Compliance with the Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS) is recommended as the best method to meet obligations under Standard III(D), ensuring standardized and ethical performance reporting.
Performance Presentation Requirements
These requirements include considering the audience's sophistication, using weighted composites of similar portfolios, including terminated accounts in the performance history, and providing necessary disclosures such as whether results are gross or net of fees.
Standard III(D): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
Apply the GIPS Standards and compliance procedures without applying GIPS Standards under Standard III(D).
Summary:
Standard III(D) emphasizes the importance of providing accurate and complete performance information, whether for separate accounts or pooled funds. Compliance with the GIPS standards is recommended for presenting performance history. Alternatively, members can meet their obligations by considering the audience's sophistication, using weighted composites, including terminated accounts, providing full disclosures, and maintaining performance data records.
Key Concepts:
GIPS Standards
Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS) are ethical standards for calculating and presenting investment performance. Compliance with GIPS ensures fair representation and full disclosure of investment performance results.
Performance Presentation
When presenting performance data, it should be done in a manner that is fair, accurate, and complete. If using brief presentations, detailed supporting information should be available upon request.
Compliance without GIPS
Members can comply with Standard III(D) without applying GIPS by tailoring the presentation to the audience's sophistication, using weighted composites of similar portfolios, including terminated accounts, providing necessary disclosures, and maintaining accurate performance records.
Standard III(D): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
Apply the GIPS Standards and demonstrate the application of Standard III(D) through various examples.
Summary:
Standard III(D) focuses on ensuring that performance presentations by members and candidates are fair, accurate, and complete. Compliance with the GIPS standards is recommended to meet these obligations. The standard also covers various scenarios where performance information might be misrepresented or not fully disclosed, emphasizing the importance of transparency and accuracy in performance reporting.
Key Concepts:
GIPS Compliance
Members and candidates claiming GIPS compliance must adhere to all its requirements, including asset-weighted performance calculations and mandatory disclosures.
Performance Presentation Accuracy
When presenting past performance, especially from previous employment, it is crucial to disclose the source and context of the performance data to avoid misleading clients.
Disclosure of Simulated Results
If simulated or model-based results are used in performance presentations, these must be clearly identified as such to ensure that the information presented is not misleading.
Inclusion of All Relevant Accounts
Performance calculations should include all relevant accounts to avoid selective reporting that could mislead potential clients about the overall performance.
Methodology Consistency and Disclosure
The methodology used for performance calculation should be consistent and clearly disclosed to clients. Any changes to the methodology should also be disclosed along with the rationale for such changes.
Standard III(E) Preservation of Confidentiality
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
Standard III(E) of the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct mandates the preservation of confidentiality regarding information related to current, former, and prospective clients. This standard is crucial unless the information pertains to illegal activities, is required by law to be disclosed, or the client permits its disclosure. The guidance provided emphasizes compliance with laws, handling electronic information securely, and cooperating with professional conduct investigations while maintaining confidentiality.
Key Concepts:
Status of Client
Confidentiality must be maintained for all current, former, and prospective clients unless explicitly authorized by the client to disclose specific information.
Compliance with Laws
Members and candidates must adhere to applicable laws that might mandate or restrict the disclosure of client information, even if it concerns illegal activities.
Electronic Information and Security
Members and candidates must be vigilant about potential accidental disclosures of client information due to the increasing use of electronic storage and communication, adhering to strict employer policies and data security laws.
Professional Conduct Investigations by CFA Institute
Cooperation with the CFA Institute's Professional Conduct Program investigations is encouraged and does not violate confidentiality standards, provided it complies with applicable laws.
Standard III(E): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
describe the recommended procedures for Standard III(E) with respect to communicating with clients
Summary:
Standard III(E) emphasizes the importance of maintaining confidentiality when handling client information. It outlines the need for compliance with applicable laws regarding disclosure and confidentiality, the importance of secure handling of electronic information, and the procedures for communicating with clients to prevent accidental distribution of confidential information. The standard also allows for cooperation with professional conduct investigations by the CFA Institute.
Key Concepts:
Compliance with Laws
Members and candidates must adhere to applicable laws concerning client information, whether it mandates disclosure or requires confidentiality, even in cases involving illegal activities by the client.
Electronic Information and Security
Due to the high volume of electronically stored information, members and candidates must be vigilant about accidental disclosures and adhere to strict employer policies regarding the communication and storage of sensitive client information.
Professional Conduct Investigations by CFA Institute
Standard III(E) allows members and candidates to cooperate with CFA Institute's Professional Conduct Program investigations without being considered in violation of confidentiality standards, provided it is permissible under applicable law.
Communicating with Clients
Members and candidates should use firm-supported communication methods and compliance procedures that are designed to prevent accidental distribution of confidential information and regularly review privacy protection measures due to rapid technological changes.
Standard III(E): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
Demonstrate the application of Standard III(E) in various scenarios involving confidential information.
Summary:
Standard III(E) of the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct focuses on the preservation and appropriate handling of confidential information. This standard is crucial for maintaining trust and integrity in professional relationships and financial dealings. The provided examples illustrate different situations where financial professionals must navigate the complexities of handling confidential information, ensuring they do not disclose it improperly, even in challenging circumstances.
Key Concepts:
Possessing Confidential Information
Financial professionals must safeguard confidential information provided by clients for specific purposes, such as investment advice, and must not disclose this information to others without explicit permission or legal obligation.
Disclosing Confidential Information
Revealing confidential client information without consent, even with good intentions (such as charity), violates Standard III(E). Professionals must always protect client confidentiality unless required by law to disclose.
Disclosing Possible Illegal Activity
When encountering potentially illegal activities, professionals should first consult with legal or compliance departments. Disclosure of confidential information may be warranted if it involves preventing or reporting illegal activities, but should be handled carefully and legally.
Accidental Disclosure of Confidential Information
Professionals must take reasonable steps to prevent accidental disclosure of confidential information. This includes advising clients on the risks of certain communication methods and promptly addressing any breaches that occur.
Standard IV: Duties to Employers
Learning Outcome Statement:
Demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity, recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violations of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct, and identify conduct that conforms to the Code and Standards and conduct that violates the Code and Standards.
Summary:
Standard IV: Duties to Employers focuses on the ethical responsibilities of members and candidates towards their employers. It emphasizes loyalty, protection of employer's interests, and compliance with established policies and procedures, while balancing these duties with the obligation to clients and the integrity of the market. The standard also covers specific scenarios such as the use of social media, independent practice, and transitioning between employers.
Key Concepts:
Loyalty to Employer
Members and candidates must act for the benefit of their employer, protect confidential information, and avoid actions that could harm their employer's interests.
Independent Practice
While still employed, members and candidates must notify their employer and obtain consent before engaging in any independent practice that could compete with the employer's interests.
Leaving an Employer
Members and candidates must continue to act in their employer's best interest until their resignation is effective, avoiding conflicts and protecting confidential information.
Use of Social Media
Members and candidates must adhere to employer policies regarding social media use, especially when it involves client interactions and when planning to leave the employer.
Whistleblowing
In cases of illegal or unethical activities by the employer, members and candidates may need to act contrary to their employer's interests to protect the integrity of the market and client interests.
Nature of Employment
The relationship type (employee or independent contractor) affects the applicability of Standard IV(A), determined by factors like control over work conditions and employment terms.
Standard IV(A): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
describe the recommended procedures under Standard IV(A)
Summary:
Standard IV(A) outlines the recommended procedures that members and candidates should follow to ensure compliance with their employer's policies and the CFA Institute's ethical standards. These procedures include understanding competition and termination policies, incident-reporting mechanisms, and employee classification.
Key Concepts:
Competition Policy
Members and candidates must be aware of any restrictions regarding offering similar services outside their current firm. This includes understanding noncompete agreements and the procedures for requesting approval to undertake outside services.
Termination Policy
It is crucial for members and candidates to understand their employer's termination policies, which should cover the resignation process, client and staff disclosure, social media updates, and the transfer of responsibilities.
Incident-Reporting Procedures
Members and candidates should be familiar with their firm's whistleblowing policies and encourage the adoption of industry best practices for confidential and anonymous reporting of unethical or illegal activities.
Employee Classification
Understanding how policies apply to different employee classes (e.g., part-time, full-time, contractor) is essential for members and candidates. Firms should have a clear classification structure that indicates the applicability of various policies.
Standard IV(A): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
Standard IV(A) focuses on the ethical obligations of employees towards their employers, particularly in scenarios involving solicitation of former clients, handling of confidential information, and competing interests. The examples provided illustrate various situations where employees must navigate conflicts of interest, confidentiality, and loyalty to their employer, ensuring they adhere to ethical standards and maintain professional integrity.
Key Concepts:
Soliciting Former Clients
Employees must avoid soliciting former clients using proprietary information from their previous employer. Actions should comply with any non-compete agreements and respect the confidentiality of client information.
Handling of Confidential Information
Employees must not take confidential information such as client lists, documents, or proprietary models from their employer without permission. This includes both physical and electronic records.
Competing with Current Employer
Employees planning to leave their current employer must avoid engaging in activities that directly compete with their employer's interests, such as responding to RFPs or starting a competing business, without explicit permission.
Whistleblowing Actions
Employees who discover unethical practices within their organization should follow internal whistleblowing policies to report these issues, ensuring they act in the best interest of the firm and its clients.
Ownership of Work Product
Employees must respect the ownership rights of work products created during their employment. Even if they participated in the creation, the output belongs to the employer unless otherwise agreed.
Standard IV(B) Additional Compensation Arrangements
Learning Outcome Statement:
Demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity, recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violations of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct, and identify conduct that conforms to the Code and Standards and conduct that violates the Code and Standards.
Summary:
Standard IV(B) Additional Compensation Arrangements requires members and candidates to obtain written consent from their employer before accepting any form of compensation or benefits from third parties that might create a conflict of interest with their employer's interests. This includes both direct and indirect compensations. The standard aims to ensure transparency and prevent conflicts of interest by maintaining employer awareness of external compensations.
Key Concepts:
Written Consent
Written consent for accepting additional compensation or benefits must be obtained from the employer. This consent can be in any form that is documentable, including emails.
Disclosure of Compensation
Members and candidates must disclose any additional compensation they propose to receive. This disclosure should include the nature, amount, and duration of the compensation.
Conflict of Interest
Accepting additional compensation without employer's consent may lead to a conflict of interest, affecting the member's or candidate's objectivity and loyalty to the employer.
Part-time Employment
For part-time employees, it is crucial to discuss potential competitive services during the hiring process to identify any limitations that might require employer's consent under Standard IV(B).
Standard IV(B): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
Describe Standard IV(B): Recommended Procedures
Summary:
Standard IV(B) of the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct requires members and candidates to report any additional compensation arrangements to their employer. This includes both monetary and non-monetary benefits that could potentially create conflicts of interest. Immediate written notification to both a supervisor and a compliance officer is mandated, detailing the nature, amount, and duration of the compensation.
Key Concepts:
Immediate Written Report
Members and candidates must provide a written report to their supervisor and compliance officer detailing any additional compensation they propose to receive. This report should include the nature, amount, and duration of the compensation.
Confirmation by the Offering Party
The details of the additional compensation must be confirmed by the party offering it. This ensures transparency and verification of the terms discussed.
Disclosure of Non-Monetary Compensation
Members and candidates must disclose any non-monetary benefits that could influence their professional decisions, such as privileges, gifts, or other perks, to avoid potential conflicts of interest.
Employer's Consent
After disclosing the additional compensation, members and candidates must obtain consent from their employer to accept such compensation. This step is crucial to maintain integrity and avoid partiality in professional duties.
Standard IV(B): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
Demonstrate the application of Standard IV(B) through examples.
Summary:
Standard IV(B) of the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct requires members and candidates to report any additional compensation arrangements to their employer. This includes both monetary and non-monetary benefits that could potentially create conflicts of interest. The standard emphasizes the importance of written notification and approval from the employer to prevent any partiality or conflict of interest in professional duties.
Key Concepts:
Notification of Additional Compensation
Members and candidates must immediately report in writing any additional compensation they propose to receive. This includes the nature, amount, and duration of the compensation.
Example 1: Client Bonus Compensation
Geoff Whitman failed to report a contingent compensation arrangement offered by a client, which could have led to partiality in managing the client's account. This is a violation of Standard IV(B).
Example 2: Outside Compensation
Terry Jones did not disclose non-monetary benefits received from serving on a board, which could create a conflict of interest. This non-disclosure is a violation of Standard IV(B).
Example 3: Prior Approval for Outside Compensation
Jonathan Hollis followed the correct procedure by obtaining approval before engaging in activities that could be seen as a conflict of interest, thus adhering to Standard IV(B).
Standard IV(C) Responsibilities of Supervisors
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity, recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violations of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct, identify conduct that conforms to the Code and Standards and conduct that violates the Code and Standards
Summary:
Standard IV(C) Responsibilities of Supervisors emphasizes the need for members and candidates to ensure compliance with applicable laws, rules, regulations, and the Code and Standards among employees under their supervision. It highlights the importance of establishing, documenting, and enforcing adequate compliance systems and procedures. Supervisors must also be proactive in detecting and addressing violations, and they should recommend or implement ethical codes and compliance procedures within their organizations.
Key Concepts:
System for Supervision
Supervisors must understand what constitutes an adequate compliance system for their firms, ensuring that appropriate compliance procedures are established, documented, communicated, and followed. These procedures should meet industry standards and regulatory requirements.
Supervision Includes Detection
Supervisors must make reasonable efforts to detect violations of laws, rules, regulations, firm policies, and the Code and Standards. This involves establishing written compliance procedures, implementing them, and conducting periodic reviews to ensure adherence.
Recommended Procedures
Members and candidates are encouraged to recommend that their employers adopt a code of ethics and compliance procedures. These codes are crucial for establishing a strong ethical foundation and for guiding the behavior of employees within investment advisory firms.
Standard IV(C): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
Describe Standard IV(C): Recommended Procedures
Summary:
Standard IV(C) emphasizes the importance of establishing, documenting, and enforcing adequate compliance procedures within investment firms to prevent violations of laws and ethical standards. It highlights the necessity of a code of ethics, adequate compliance procedures, regular compliance education and training, and an appropriate incentive structure to promote ethical behavior and compliance with legal and regulatory requirements.
Key Concepts:
Codes of Ethics vs. Compliance Procedures
Codes of ethics establish fundamental ethical principles applicable to all employees, emphasizing client loyalty and integrity. Compliance procedures are detailed policies that ensure adherence to these codes and legal standards, helping to prevent misconduct.
Adequate Compliance Procedures
These procedures should be clearly written, easily understandable, and tailored to the firm's operations. They should include a designated compliance officer, a clear hierarchy of supervision, checks and balances, and mechanisms for reporting violations.
Implementation of Compliance Education and Training
Regular training programs are essential to reinforce the firm's code of ethics and help employees recognize and avoid ethical and legal pitfalls. These programs link ethical behavior to the long-term success of the business and emphasize a culture of integrity.
Appropriate Incentive Structure
The incentive structure within a firm should align with ethical behavior and client interests. It should discourage unethical practices by not solely focusing on profits but also on how outcomes are achieved, promoting a culture of integrity.
Standard IV(C): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
Demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
This LOS explores various scenarios where the Standard IV(C) of the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct is applied. It discusses different examples of supervisory responsibilities in research and trading activities, highlighting the importance of adequate supervision, proper procedures, and the consequences of failing to adhere to these standards.
Key Concepts:
Adequate Supervision
Supervisors must ensure that there are effective controls and procedures to prevent misconduct and protect client interests. This includes preventing unauthorized dissemination of information and ensuring all trading and research activities are conducted ethically and legally.
Proper Procedures
Organizations must have documented and communicated procedures that are designed to prevent violations of ethical and professional standards. This includes procedures for reviewing research reports, trading activities, and ensuring compliance with all regulatory requirements.
Consequences of Inadequate Supervision
Failing to provide adequate supervision can lead to unethical practices, such as insider trading or manipulation of market prices. This not only harms the clients but also undermines the integrity of the financial markets and the reputation of the supervising individual and the firm.
Standard V: Investment Analysis, Recommendations, and Actions
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity, recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violations of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct, identify conduct that conforms to the Code and Standards and conduct that violates the Code and Standards
Summary:
Standard V(A) of the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct focuses on the diligence and reasonable basis required in investment analysis, recommendations, and actions. It emphasizes the need for thorough research and investigation to support investment decisions and outlines the use of various research methodologies, including secondary and third-party research, quantitatively oriented research, and the selection of external advisers and subadvisers.
Key Concepts:
Diligence and Reasonable Basis
Members and candidates must exercise diligence, independence, and thoroughness in analyzing investments, making investment recommendations, and taking investment actions. They must have a reasonable and adequate basis, supported by appropriate research and investigation, for any investment analysis, recommendation, or action.
Using Secondary or Third-Party Research
When relying on secondary or third-party research, members and candidates must make reasonable and diligent efforts to determine whether such research is sound. They should verify the source and accuracy of all data used in their investment analysis and recommendations.
Using Quantitatively Oriented Research
Members and candidates need to understand the parameters, assumptions, and limitations of quantitatively oriented research models and processes. They should ensure that their analyses incorporate a broad range of assumptions sufficient to capture the underlying characteristics of investments.
Selecting External Advisers and Subadvisers
When selecting external advisers or subadvisers, members and candidates must review managers as diligently as they review individual funds and securities. They need to ensure that their firms have standardized criteria for reviewing these selected external advisers and managers.
Group Research and Decision Making
In group research settings, the conclusions or recommendations represent the consensus of the group and are not necessarily the views of the individual member or candidate. If the consensus opinion has a reasonable and adequate basis and is independent and objective, the member or candidate need not decline to be identified with the report.
Standard V(A): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
Describe Standard V(A): Recommended Procedures
Summary:
Standard V(A) focuses on the ethical responsibilities of members and candidates in group research and decision-making processes. It emphasizes the importance of having a reasonable and adequate basis for investment recommendations and ensuring that research reports, credit ratings, and investment recommendations are substantiated. The standard also outlines recommended procedures for firms to support these principles, including establishing policies for due diligence, scenario testing, and evaluating external advisers.
Key Concepts:
Group Research and Decision Making
In a group setting, the consensus represents the collective opinion, which may not necessarily reflect individual views. Members or candidates should ensure the group's opinion has a reasonable basis and is independent before associating their names with the report.
Establishing Reasonable and Adequate Basis
Firms should have policies ensuring that research reports and investment recommendations are based on substantiated, reasonable, and adequate grounds. This involves appointing individuals or committees to review such items before they are circulated externally.
Due Diligence Procedures
Firms should develop written guidance for analysts and review committees outlining the procedures to judge if a recommendation has a reasonable and adequate basis, including detailed scenario testing for computer-based models.
Measurable Criteria for Quality Assessment
Firms should develop criteria to assess the quality of research, the adequacy of recommendations, and the accuracy of information over time. This may include compensation arrangements based on these criteria.
Evaluating External Advisers and Providers
Policies should be established to regularly review external advisers and providers, assessing the quality and accuracy of the information provided and the adequacy of their collection practices.
Standard V(A): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
Demonstrate the application of Standard V(A) in various scenarios.
Summary:
Standard V(A) emphasizes the importance of diligence, independence, and thoroughness in analyzing investments, making investment recommendations, and taking investment actions. The examples provided illustrate various situations where investment professionals either adhere to or violate this standard by either conducting sufficient due diligence or failing to establish a reasonable basis for investment decisions.
Key Concepts:
Sufficient Due Diligence
Due diligence involves a comprehensive appraisal of a business or person prior to signing a contract, or an act with a certain standard of care. It can be a legal obligation, but the term more commonly applies to voluntary investigations. A common example of due diligence in various industries is the process through which a potential acquirer evaluates a target company or its assets for an acquisition.
Developing a Reasonable Basis
Developing a reasonable basis requires that investment professionals conduct a thorough analysis and gather sufficient information to justify their investment recommendations. This includes understanding the nature and risks of the investment, as well as the client's objectives and constraints.
Timely Client Updates
Investment professionals must keep their clients informed about significant changes that could affect their investment decisions. This includes updating clients about material changes in the investment outlook or in the investment itself.
Reliance on Third-Party Research
While it is acceptable to use third-party research, investment professionals must ensure that they conduct their own due diligence to confirm the accuracy and reliability of the research before making investment recommendations based on it.
Quantitatively Oriented Models
When using quantitatively oriented models, investment professionals must understand the underlying assumptions, limitations, and potential risks associated with the models. They must ensure that the models are robust and have been tested under various conditions.
Standard V(B) Communication with Clients and Prospective Clients
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
Standard V(B) Communication with Clients and Prospective Clients emphasizes the importance of clear, accurate, and thorough communication in maintaining high-quality financial services. It mandates members and candidates to disclose the nature of services, costs, investment processes, and significant risks to clients, ensuring clients can make informed decisions. The standard also requires distinguishing between facts and opinions in communications and maintaining transparency about the limitations of investment processes and models.
Key Concepts:
Nature of Services and Information on Cost
Members must disclose the nature of the services provided and the costs associated with these services to clients and prospective clients, enabling them to make informed decisions.
Informing Clients of the Investment Process
It is crucial for members to explain their investment process, including how they select securities and construct portfolios, and to promptly disclose any changes that might materially affect these processes.
Different Forms of Communication
Communication can occur through various mediums such as written reports, presentations, or digital communications. Members must ensure that all forms of communication are clear and accessible to all clients.
Identifying Risk and Limitations
Members must clearly outline significant risks and limitations associated with their investment processes to clients, ensuring that clients are aware of potential impacts on their investments.
Report Presentation
Reports should clearly present the analysis and conclusions, distinguishing between facts and opinions, and should be supported by adequate investigation and reference material.
Distinction between Facts and Opinions in Reports
It is essential to distinguish between factual information and opinions or projections in investment reports to prevent misinterpretations and ensure clarity.
Standard V(B): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
Describe Standard V(B): Recommended Procedures
Summary:
Standard V(B) emphasizes the importance of using reasonable judgment in the inclusion and exclusion of information in research reports, promoting rigorous review methodologies within firms, and maintaining transparency with clients regarding assumptions and methodologies used in investment models. It also highlights the need for disclosure of compensation arrangements and the potential conflicts of interest that may arise from non-disclosure.
Key Concepts:
Reasonable Judgment in Research
The selection of relevant factors in research reports is an analytical skill, and the determination of whether a member has used reasonable judgment is based on a case-by-case review, not a fixed checklist.
Rigorous Review Methodology
Firms are encouraged to implement a rigorous methodology for reviewing research created for publication and dissemination to clients, ensuring accuracy and reliability of the information provided.
Transparency and Disclosure
Members must maintain records of their research and be prepared to provide additional information about factors not included in reports. Disclosure of compensation arrangements, especially those that could influence investment decisions, is crucial to avoid conflicts of interest.
Case Examples
Examples provided illustrate violations of Standard V(B), such as non-disclosure of compensation arrangements that could influence investment decisions, highlighting the importance of transparency and ethical conduct in financial advising.
Standard V(B): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
Standard V(B) of the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct focuses on the proper communication and disclosure of information to clients and prospective clients. It emphasizes the importance of transparency in fee structures, investment processes, and any changes to them. The standard requires that investment professionals disclose all relevant information that could affect the client's decision-making process, including changes in investment strategies, fee calculations, and potential risks and limitations of investment products.
Key Concepts:
Disclosure of Fee Structures
Investment professionals must clearly communicate any fees charged for their services, including how these fees are calculated and any changes to fee structures.
Transparency in Investment Processes
Professionals should disclose the methodologies and assumptions used in their investment processes. Any changes to these processes must also be communicated to clients.
Notification of Changes
Clients must be informed about significant changes in investment strategies or processes, such as changes in valuation models or investment mandates.
Risks and Limitations
Investment professionals should disclose the risks and limitations associated with the investment strategies they employ, ensuring clients understand potential downsides.
Standard V(C) Record Retention
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
Standard V(C) Record Retention emphasizes the importance of maintaining appropriate records to support investment analyses, recommendations, actions, and communications with clients. It covers the types of records that should be retained, the formats acceptable, and the ownership and legal requirements concerning these records.
Key Concepts:
Types of Records
Members and candidates must retain records that substantiate their research and reasons for actions or conclusions. This includes personal notes, press releases, computer-based model outputs and inputs, risk analyses, selection criteria for external advisers, and outside research reports.
New Media Records
With the rise of digital communication, members are required to retain records in new media formats such as emails, text messages, blog posts, and social media posts. This ensures that all relevant information used in analyses or communicated to clients is preserved, regardless of the format.
Records Ownership
Records created during professional activities are generally the property of the firm. If a member or candidate changes employment, they cannot take these records without explicit consent from the previous employer. Any future use of past records at a new firm must be recreated from public sources or directly from the covered company.
Local Requirements
Local regulations may impose specific record retention requirements. In the absence of such regulations, the CFA Institute recommends maintaining records for at least seven years to comply with Standard V(C).
Standard V(C): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
Describe the recommended procedures for Standard V(C)
Summary:
Standard V(C) emphasizes the importance of maintaining accurate and comprehensive records to support investment actions and communications. It covers the challenges posed by new media, the ownership of records, and local regulatory requirements. The standard mandates that records should be retained to support investment decisions and communications, and these records are generally the property of the firm, not the individual.
Key Concepts:
New Media Records
With the rise of digital communication, members and candidates must ensure that all relevant information shared through new media (e.g., emails, social media posts) is retained, despite the lack of immediate policies from employers or regulators.
Records Are Property of the Firm
Records created during professional activities are owned by the firm. Employees cannot take these records when they leave a firm unless they have explicit permission. Any use of historical data at a new firm must be supported by newly created or publicly sourced records.
Local Requirements
Local regulations may dictate specific record retention requirements. In the absence of such regulations, the CFA Institute recommends retaining records for at least seven years to comply with Standard V(C).
Standard V(C): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
This LOS focuses on demonstrating how the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct are applied in various professional scenarios to maintain integrity. It includes examples related to record retention, research processes, and property rights of records within a firm.
Key Concepts:
Record Retention and IPS Objectives
Maintaining accurate records is crucial to demonstrate compliance with investment strategies and client agreements, as shown in the example of Nikolas Lindstrom, who needed to prove that his investment allocations were in line with the agreed-upon benchmarks in the client's IPS.
Record Retention and Research Process
Researchers like Malcolm Young must document all sources and information used in their reports to ensure transparency and accountability, safeguarding against potential violations of Standard V(C).
Records as Firm Property
Records created during employment are the property of the firm, not the employee. Martin Blank's example illustrates the violation of Standard V(C) when he took proprietary records to a new employer without permission.
Standard VI: Conflicts of Interest
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
Standard VI: Conflicts of Interest focuses on the ethical responsibilities of members and candidates in the investment profession to avoid or disclose conflicts of interest that could impair their independence and objectivity. It emphasizes the importance of clear, prominent, and effective communication of any conflicts to clients, prospective clients, and employers to maintain transparency and uphold the integrity of investment advice and actions.
Key Concepts:
Avoidance or Disclosure of Conflicts
Members and candidates must avoid conflicts of interest or disclose them fully if unavoidable. This ensures that their independence and objectivity are not compromised, maintaining trust and integrity in their professional duties.
Disclosure Practices
Disclosures must be prominent, delivered in plain language, and effectively communicate the relevant information. This includes updating disclosures when the nature of a conflict changes materially.
Conflicts with Employers and Clients
Conflicts must be disclosed to both employers and clients. This includes conflicts arising from personal stock ownership, relationships with companies, or external positions such as board memberships that might influence professional judgment.
Cross-Departmental and Stock Ownership Conflicts
Conflicts can arise from various departmental interactions within a firm or from personal or direct stock ownership in advised companies. These conflicts must be managed or disclosed according to Standard VI(A).
Board Membership Conflicts
Serving as a board member or director can create conflicts between duties to clients and duties to the company. Such positions may also provide access to material nonpublic information, requiring careful management and disclosure.
Standard VI(A): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
Demonstrate the application of Standard VI(A) in various conflict of interest scenarios.
Summary:
Standard VI(A) of the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct addresses conflicts of interest that can arise in various business relationships and personal stock ownership situations. The standard requires disclosure of conflicts and, in some cases, avoidance of the conflict by not participating in certain activities or decisions. The examples provided illustrate how conflicts of interest can manifest and the appropriate responses to maintain professional integrity and comply with the standard.
Key Concepts:
Conflict of Interest and Business Relationships
When a firm or its employees have a special relationship with a company they are reporting on, this relationship must be disclosed to maintain transparency and objectivity.
Conflict of Interest and Business Stock Ownership
Ownership interests in a company by a firm or its employees can create conflicts of interest when making investment recommendations. Disclosure of these interests is essential, and best practice may require ceasing coverage of the company.
Conflict of Interest and Personal Stock Ownership
Personal ownership of stock in companies that an analyst covers can impair objectivity. Disclosure to both the employer and in any reports is necessary, and reassignment of the coverage to another analyst is recommended.
Conflict of Interest and Compensation Arrangements
Compensation arrangements that incentivize behavior contrary to client interests, such as rewarding short-term performance when managing long-term investments, must be disclosed to clients.
Conflict of Interest and Requested Favors
Personal relationships that might influence business decisions, such as selecting external managers for investments, should be disclosed to allow employers to assess the potential conflict.
Standard VI(B) Priority of Transactions
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity, recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violations of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct, identify conduct that conforms to the Code and Standards and conduct that violates the Code and Standards
Summary:
Standard VI(B) Priority of Transactions emphasizes the importance of prioritizing client and employer transactions over personal transactions to avoid conflicts of interest and maintain professional integrity. It outlines guidelines and recommended procedures to manage potential conflicts effectively and ensure compliance with ethical standards.
Key Concepts:
Priority of Client Transactions
Investment transactions for clients and employers must take precedence over personal transactions to prevent conflicts of interest and ensure that client interests are served first.
Avoiding Potential Conflicts
Conflicts of interest should be avoided by ensuring that personal trading does not disadvantage clients, benefit the professional from client trades, or violate regulatory requirements.
Personal Trading Secondary to Client Trading
Personal transactions should not adversely affect client investments and should be conducted only after clients and employers have had the opportunity to act on recommendations.
Standards for Nonpublic Information
Members and candidates must not use nonpublic information for personal gain or convey this information to others who could use it for securities trading.
Impact on All Accounts with Beneficial Ownership
Transactions in accounts where the member or candidate has a beneficial ownership must be secondary to client transactions, and family accounts should be treated equitably without special treatment.
Recommended Procedures
Firms should establish clear policies and procedures to manage conflicts of interest in personal transactions, including restrictions on participation in IPOs and private placements.
Standard VI(B): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
describe the recommended procedures under Standard VI(B) to manage conflicts of interest in personal trading activities
Summary:
Standard VI(B) emphasizes the importance of establishing policies and procedures to manage conflicts of interest in personal trading activities to maintain investor confidence. It outlines specific procedures such as restrictions on participation in IPOs and private placements, establishing blackout periods, enforcing reporting requirements, and fully disclosing these policies to investors.
Key Concepts:
Limited participation in equity IPOs
Investment personnel are advised against participating in IPOs to avoid conflicts of interest, such as taking away investment opportunities from clients or appearing to receive favorable treatment from issuers.
Restrictions on private placements
Strict limits should be placed on investment personnel acquiring securities in private placements to prevent conflicts of interest that may arise from receiving special opportunities as incentives.
Establish blackout/restricted periods
Blackout periods should be established to prevent investment personnel from using insider knowledge to trade ahead of client transactions, a practice known as 'front-running'.
Reporting requirements
Investment personnel must disclose personal holdings and trade confirmations to their firms. Preclearance of trades is required to identify and manage potential conflicts of interest.
Disclosure of policies
Firms must fully disclose their personal trading policies to investors, ensuring transparency and addressing public concerns about potential conflicts of interest.
Standard VI(B): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
This LOS focuses on applying Standard VI(B) of the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct, which deals with personal trading and conflicts of interest. It provides examples of both adherence and violations related to personal trading, trading for family members, and the importance of disclosure to prevent conflicts of interest.
Key Concepts:
Disclosure of Personal Trading Policies
Members and candidates must fully disclose their firm's policies on personal investing to investors to ensure transparency and address public concerns about potential conflicts of interest.
Priority of Client Transactions
Investment professionals must place client transactions ahead of personal or family transactions to avoid conflicts of interest and ensure fair treatment of all clients.
Equal Treatment of Family Accounts
Managing family accounts requires that they be treated equally to other client accounts, without any preferential treatment, unless disclosed and in compliance with firm policies.
Disclosure of Trading Activities
Investment professionals must disclose their trading activities, especially when trading could potentially conflict with client interests or firm policies.
Preventing Misuse of Information
Professionals must avoid using nonpublic or insider information for personal gain or before it is available to clients, to maintain market integrity and comply with ethical standards.
Standard VI(C) Referral Fees
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
Standard VI(C) Referral Fees emphasizes the importance of transparency in disclosing any compensation, consideration, or benefit received or paid for recommending products or services. It outlines the need for members and candidates to inform their employer, clients, and prospective clients about such benefits to allow for informed decisions regarding potential biases and the total cost of services.
Key Concepts:
Disclosure of Compensation
Members and candidates must disclose any compensation or benefits they receive or pay for referrals, ensuring transparency in their professional relationships and allowing clients and employers to assess potential conflicts of interest and overall service costs.
Nature and Value of Consideration
The disclosure must include the nature of the consideration (e.g., flat fee, percentage basis) and its estimated dollar value. This helps in providing a clear and comprehensive understanding of the benefits involved.
Employer Procedures on Referral Fees
Members and candidates should encourage their employers to establish clear procedures regarding referral fees, which may include restrictions or detailed approval processes, to maintain ethical standards within the firm.
Regular Updates to Employers
Investment professionals are advised to provide regular updates to their employers about the nature and amount of referral compensation received, promoting ongoing transparency and adherence to ethical standards.
Standard VI(C): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
Standard VI(C) of the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct focuses on the disclosure of referral fees. It mandates that members and candidates must inform their employer, clients, and prospective clients about any compensation or benefits received or paid for recommendations of products or services. The standard aims to ensure transparency and allow clients to evaluate any potential biases in recommendations.
Key Concepts:
Disclosure of Referral Fees
Members and candidates are required to disclose any compensation, consideration, or benefit they receive or pay for recommending products or services. This disclosure helps clients and employers assess the impartiality and total cost of the services recommended.
Nature and Value of Consideration
The disclosure must include the nature of the consideration (e.g., flat fee, percentage basis) and its estimated dollar value. This includes all forms of fees, whether paid in cash, in soft dollars, or in kind.
Procedures for Managing Referral Fees
Firms are encouraged to develop procedures related to referral fees, which may include restrictions or guidelines for approval. Regular updates on the nature and amount of compensation received should be provided to the employer.
Application of Standard VI(C)
Examples provided illustrate violations of Standard VI(C), such as failing to disclose referral arrangements or internal referral payments. These examples emphasize the importance of full disclosure to maintain professional integrity and client trust.
Standard VI(C): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
This LOS focuses on demonstrating the application of Standard VI(C) through various examples that illustrate the importance of disclosing referral arrangements and conflicts of interest in maintaining professional integrity. Each example highlights a scenario where the standard is either violated or upheld, providing insights into the ethical considerations and obligations of financial professionals under the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct.
Key Concepts:
Disclosure of Referral Arrangements
Financial professionals must disclose any referral arrangements that might influence their recommendations. This includes both external and internal referral payments, ensuring that clients can make informed decisions about the services they are receiving.
Informing Employers and Clients
It is crucial for professionals to inform both their employers and their clients about any referral arrangements or conflicts of interest that could impact their professional duties or influence their decision-making process.
Regulatory Compliance
Professionals must also adhere to local regulations concerning referral arrangements and conflicts of interest, which may include registering with a regulatory agency's ethics board and reporting contributions to political organizations.
Standard VII: Responsibilities as a CFA Institute Member or CFA Candidate
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity, recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violations of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct, identify conduct that conforms to the Code and Standards and conduct that violates the Code and Standards
Summary:
Standard VII: Responsibilities as a CFA Institute Member or CFA Candidate outlines the ethical responsibilities of CFA members and candidates, particularly in relation to their conduct during CFA Institute programs. It emphasizes maintaining the integrity, validity, and security of these programs and prohibits any conduct that could compromise the reputation of the CFA Institute or the CFA designation.
Key Concepts:
Confidential Program Information
CFA Institute strictly prohibits the disclosure of confidential material related to its programs and exams. This includes specific exam questions, broad topical areas, and formulas tested or not tested, ensuring the integrity and rigor of exams for future candidates.
Additional CFA Program Restrictions
Candidates must adhere to specific rules and regulations during exams, such as the calculator policy and personal belongings policy. Violations of these policies constitute a breach of Standard VII(A).
Expressing an Opinion
While members and candidates can express opinions about CFA Institute policies or procedures, they must not disclose exam-specific content or subject matter covered in the exams when doing so.
Standard VII(A): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
demonstrate the application of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situations involving issues of professional integrity
Summary:
This LOS focuses on applying Standard VII(A) of the CFA Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct through various examples that illustrate potential violations in different scenarios, including exam conduct, sharing confidential information, and misuse of volunteer positions. Each example demonstrates how actions can compromise the integrity and validity of the CFA exam or the reputation of the CFA Institute.
Key Concepts:
Sharing Exam Questions
Providing or receiving information about exam questions before or after the exam compromises the integrity and fairness of the exam, violating Standard VII(A).
Bringing Written Material into Exam Room
Entering the exam room with unauthorized written material, such as formulas, is a direct violation of Standard VII(A) as it undermines the validity of the exam performance.
Writing after Exam Period End
Continuing to write after the exam has officially ended provides an unfair advantage and compromises the exam's integrity, violating Standard VII(A).
Sharing Exam Content
Discussing or posting exam content publicly can assist future candidates unfairly and compromise the confidentiality of the exam content, violating Standard VII(A).
Compromising CFA Institute Integrity as a Volunteer
Using a volunteer position for personal or client gain, or sharing confidential information gained through such positions, compromises the reputation and integrity of the CFA Institute, violating Standard VII(A).
Standard VII(B): Recommended Procedures
Learning Outcome Statement:
Describe Standard VII(B): Recommended Procedures
Summary:
Standard VII(B) of the CFA Institute's ethical guidelines focuses on the proper use and reference to the CFA designation and candidacy. It outlines how candidates and charterholders should represent their status and achievements without implying superior ability or misleading others about the significance of the CFA designation. The standard also emphasizes the importance of consistent and accurate communication within firms regarding CFA status and the need for compliance with these guidelines.
Key Concepts:
Misuse of CFA Designation
Misuse of the CFA designation or candidacy occurs when individuals inaccurately represent their CFA status or imply superior abilities based on their CFA achievements. This includes linking passing exams on the first attempt to superior investment performance or claiming a partial designation.
Proper References to CFA Designation
Proper references to the CFA designation should accurately reflect one's status without suggesting superiority or guaranteed outcomes. Examples include stating factual achievements like passing exams or enrolling in the CFA Program without implying enhanced abilities or outcomes.
Role of Compliance and Consistency
Firms are encouraged to develop templates for referencing CFA status that are approved by a central authority like the compliance department. This ensures consistency and accuracy in how CFA status is communicated, reducing the risk of misrepresentation.
Reinstatement of CFA Designation
If a CFA charterholder lapses in their professional conduct or dues, they must cease using the CFA designation until they have reinstated their membership by fulfilling all necessary requirements, including filing a Professional Conduct Statement and paying dues.
Standard VII(B): Application of the Standard
Learning Outcome Statement:
Apply Standard VII(B) in various scenarios.
Summary:
Standard VII(B) of the CFA Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct focuses on the proper use and representation of the CFA designation. It mandates that members and candidates ensure accurate and consistent representation of their CFA status in communications and marketing materials. The standard also covers the implications of not maintaining active membership and the correct order of professional designations.
Key Concepts:
Use of CFA Designation
Members must maintain active membership, which includes filing a Professional Conduct Statement and paying dues, to use the CFA designation. Failure to do so results in suspension of the right to use the designation.
Linking CFA Status to Performance
It is inappropriate to link passing CFA exams or holding the CFA designation directly to superior investment performance or abilities.
Representation in Marketing
Firms should use templates approved by a central authority like the compliance department to ensure consistency and accuracy when referencing CFA Institute membership or designation.
Order of Professional Designations
The order of citing professional and academic designations on business cards or resumes is a matter of personal preference, but they must be separated by commas.
Use of Fictitious Names
Using a fictitious name in conjunction with the CFA designation is inappropriate. Authorship of any publication or online content that includes the CFA designation must clearly state the full name of the charterholder.